Case details

Court: ca2
Docket #: 13-3088
Case Name: Floyd v. City of New York
PACER case #: 13-3088
Date filed: 2013-08-16
Date terminated: 2014-10-31
Nature of Suit: 3440 CIVIL RIGHTS-Other

Documents

Date Filed Document # Attachment # Short Description Long Description Upload date SHA1 hash
2013-08-16 1 0 NOTICE OF CIVIL APPEAL, with district court docket, on behalf of Appellant City of New York, FILED. [1019143] [13-3088]
1 1 Case FILED 2013-08-19 10:37:49 2a8f0fe1cd9e6fb1efb5313faf10adf62f039ec4
1 2 Dkt_Ntc_BK_CV_PR_Tax
2013-08-16 2 0 DISTRICT COURT ORDER, dated 08/12/2013, RECEIVED.[1019154] [13-3088]
2013-08-16 3 0 ELECTRONIC INDEX, in lieu of record, FILED.[1019155] [13-3088]
3 1 Index/FRAP 10(d) in lieu of ROA FILED
3 2 Notice_of_Index_or_ROA_Filed
2013-08-21 8 0 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS ADDITIONAL COUNSEL, on behalf of -- Michael Bloomberg, Raymond Kelly, New York City Police Officer Goodman, New York City Police Officer Hernandez, New York City Police Officer Joyce, New York City Police Officer Pichardo, New York City Police Officer Rodriguez, New York City Police Officer Salmerson, New York City Police Officers John and Jane Does, New York City Police Sergeant Kelly, New York Police Officer Moran and Appellant City of New York, FILED. Service date 08/21/2013 by CM/ECF. [1022289] [13-3088]
2013-08-21 9 0 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS ADDITIONAL COUNSEL, on behalf of Appellant City of New York, FILED. Service date 08/21/2013 by CM/ECF. [1022409] [13-3088]
2013-08-21 13 0 DEFECTIVE DOCUMENT,acknowledgment and notice of appearance, [10], on behalf of Appellee Lalit Clarkson, Deon Dennis, David Floyd and David Ourlicht, FILED.[1022601] [13-3088]
2013-08-24 15 0 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS ADDITIONAL COUNSEL, on behalf of Appellant City of New York, FILED. Service date 08/24/2013 by CM/ECF. [1025368] [13-3088]
2013-08-26 17 0 ACKNOWLEDGMENT AND NOTICE OF APPEARANCE, on behalf of Appellee Lalit Clarkson, Deon Dennis, David Floyd and David Ourlicht, FILED. Service date 08/26/2013 by CM/ECF.[1025598] [13-3088]
2013-08-27 19 0 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS ADDITIONAL COUNSEL, on behalf of Appellee Lalit Clarkson, Deon Dennis, David Floyd and David Ourlicht, FILED. Service date 08/27/2013 by CM/ECF. [1027365] [13-3088]
2013-08-29 21 0 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS SUBSTITUTE COUNSEL, on behalf of Appellant City of New York, FILED. Service date 08/29/2013 by CM/ECF. [1029247] [13-3088]
2013-08-29 22 0 FORM C, on behalf of Appellant City of New York, FILED. Service date 08/29/2013 by CM/ECF.[1029428] [13-3088]
2013-08-29 23 0 FORM D, on behalf of Appellant City of New York, FILED. Service date 08/29/2013 by CM/ECF.[1029430] [13-3088]
2013-08-29 29 0 NEW CASE MANAGER, Jason Wang, ASSIGNED.[1029525] [13-3088]
2013-08-30 30 0 ACKNOWLEDGMENT AND NOTICE OF APPEARANCE, on behalf of Appellant City of New York, FILED. Service date 08/30/2013 by CM/ECF.[1029885] [13-3088]
2013-09-03 32 0 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS ADDITIONAL COUNSEL, on behalf of Appellee Lalit Clarkson, Deon Dennis, David Floyd and David Ourlicht, FILED. Service date 09/03/2013 by CM/ECF. [1031682] [13-3088]
2013-09-04 34 0 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS ADDITIONAL COUNSEL, on behalf of Appellee Lalit Clarkson, Deon Dennis, David Floyd and David Ourlicht, FILED. Service date 09/04/2013 by CM/ECF. [1032822] [13-3088]
2013-09-06 38 0 DEFECTIVE DOCUMENT, notice of appearance[37], on behalf of Appellee Lalit Clarkson, Deon Dennis, David Floyd and David Ourlicht, FILED.[1035037] [13-3088]
2013-09-06 39 0 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS ADDITIONAL COUNSEL, on behalf of Appellee Lalit Clarkson, Deon Dennis, David Floyd and David Ourlicht, FILED. Service date 09/06/2013 by CM/ECF. [1035054] [13-3088]
2013-09-06 42 0 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS ADDITIONAL COUNSEL, on behalf of Appellee Lalit Clarkson, Deon Dennis, David Floyd and David Ourlicht, FILED. Service date 09/06/2013 by CM/ECF. [1035221] [13-3088]
2013-09-11 44 0 MOTION, to expedite appeal, and to be heard in tandem with 13-3123, on behalf of Appellant City of New York, FILED. Service date 09/11/2013 by CM/ECF. [1038738] [13-3088]--[Edited 09/12/2013 by JW]
2013-09-13 47 0 MOTION, to file oversized brief, to waive a requirement, on behalf of Appellant City of New York, FILED. Service date 09/13/2013 by CM/ECF. [1040686] [13-3088]
2013-09-17 50 0 OPPOSITION TO MOTION to expedite appeal [44], on behalf of Appellee Lalit Clarkson, Deon Dennis, David Floyd and David Ourlicht, FILED. Service date 09/17/2013 by CM/ECF. [1043123][50] [13-3088]
50 1 Memorandum of Law in Opposition to Motion to Expedite FILED 2013-09-17 16:58:13 6105cc45992f796c53728c6771b4f1508d6bd163
50 2 Exhibits A through E 2013-09-17 16:57:25 b426169a1b7d3fb5b039f5f6eeff03fbd7316366
50 3 Declaration in Opposition to Motion 2013-09-17 16:59:12 5d56007c1c45e4bcf717754c1f5dc9a3336e5f35
2013-09-12 52 0 NOTICE OF CIVIL APPEAL, with district court docket, on behalf of Appellant Sergeants Benevolent Association, FILED. [1044410] [13-3461]
2013-09-12 53 0 DISTRICT COURT ORDER, dated 08/12/2013, RECEIVED.[1044420] [13-3461]
2013-09-12 54 0 DISTRICT COURT ORDER, dated 08/12/2013, RECEIVED.[1044423] [13-3461]
2013-09-18 55 0 NEW CASE 13-3461, on behalf of Sergeants Benevolent Association, FILED.[1044436] [13-3088]
2013-09-19 61 0 MOTION ORDER, denying motion to expedite appeal but granting the request to be heard in tandem with 13-3123(L) [44] filed by Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, by RCW, FILED. [1046257][61] [13-3088, 13-3461] 2013-09-19 15:26:38 943b911a0a8f44d3de22ebec78b7628eb4439d9d
2013-09-19 63 0 SCHEDULING NOTIFICATION, on behalf of Appellant City of New York, informing Court of proposed due date 11/29/2013, RECEIVED. Service date 09/19/2013 by CM/ECF.[1046523] [13-3088, 13-3461] 2013-09-20 18:38:14 d2a9c31dfa5b0897076577ecb1024a874a4e0403
2013-09-20 67 0 SO-ORDERED SCHEDULING NOTIFICATION, setting Appellant City of New York in 13-3088 Brief due date as 11/29/2013; Joint Appendix due date as 11/29/2013, FILED.[1047308] [13-3088, 13-3461] 2013-09-20 18:37:39 fde536a647231427dc16a38faef6d84390a74bdd
2013-09-20 68 0 NOTICE, for the submission of additional paper copies of the appendix or joint appendix, SENT.[1047311] [13-3088, 13-3461]
2013-09-13 69 0 NOTICE OF CIVIL APPEAL, with district court docket, on behalf of Appellant Detectives' Endowment Association, Inc., Lieutenants Benevolent Association of the City of New York, Inc., NYPD Captains Endowment Association and Patrolmen's Benevolent Association of the City of New York, Inc. in 13-3524, FILED. [1048287] [13-3524, 13-3088]
2013-09-23 71 0 ELECTRONIC INDEX, in lieu of record, FILED.[1048346] [13-3524, 13-3088]
2013-09-23 72 0 MOTION, to stay, on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 09/23/2013 by CM/ECF. [1048966] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-09-24 75 0 MOTION ORDER, granting in part motion to file oversized brief and to dispense with certain requirements for the appendix[47] filed by Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, by DC, FILED. [1049328][75] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524] 2013-09-24 10:43:45 22c375969f63321710067c54150d06b0af48f7fd
2013-09-24 76 0 MOTION, to dismiss, on behalf of Appellee Lalit Clarkson, Deon Dennis, David Floyd and David Ourlicht, FILED. Service date 09/24/2013 by CM/ECF. [1050031] [13-3088]
76 1 Motion to Dismiss Appeal FILED 2013-09-24 16:37:10 139b1c4523ddb42ede3c4e424aebb4e88acf0f49
76 2 Declaration of Rolnick Borchetta in Support of Motion to Dismiss Appeal 2013-09-24 16:39:25 d95d4685bf1b319a754d0fc395284b31fd81e473
76 3 Memorandum of Law in Support of Motion to Dismiss Appeal 2013-09-24 16:38:27 1d131e0412df34ca54f58951df9df2ad365219e1
2013-09-25 79 0 DEFECTIVE DOCUMENT, FRAP 42b stipulation[78], on behalf of Intervenor-Appellant Patrolmen's Benevolent Association of the City of New York, Inc., Detectives' Endowment Association, Inc., NYPD Captains Endowment Association and Lieutenants Benevolent Association of the City of New York, Inc., FILED.[1050905] [13-3524, 13-3088, 13-3461]
2013-09-25 80 0 FRAP 42 STIPULATION, With Prejudice, RECEIVED. Service date 09/25/2013 by CM/ECF.[1050919] [13-3524, 13-3088, 13-3461]
2013-09-25 87 0 FRAP 42 STIPULATION, with prejudice, FILED.[1051285] [13-3524]
2013-09-25 88 0 CERTIFIED COPY OF ORDER, dated 09/25/2013, disposing of the appeal to SDNY, ISSUED.[Mandate][1051288] [13-3524]
2013-09-26 93 0 CAMP CONFERENCE ORDER: Type of Conference: In-Person, Scheduled Date of Conference: 10/21/2013, Start Time: 10:30 AM, endorsed by Vidya Kurella, FILED.[1052063] [13-3088] 2013-09-28 03:36:45 6d36a95c34183381ecd0b96c1e1c9c796d4c6aaa
2013-09-26 94 0 FORM C, on behalf of Appellant Sergeants Benevolent Association in 13-3088, 13-3461, FILED. Service date 09/26/2013 by CM/ECF.[1052079] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-09-26 95 0 FORM D, on behalf of Appellant Sergeants Benevolent Association in 13-3088, 13-3461, FILED. Service date 09/26/2013 by CM/ECF.[1052081] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524] 2013-09-28 03:38:57 a8255c77517cbedce7c81a649e4190d6b76fc0c1
2013-09-26 99 0 NEW CASE MANAGER, Jason Wang, ASSIGNED.[1052343] [13-3461]
2013-09-26 101 0 AMENDED CAPTION PAGE, removed proposed-intervenors-appellants Patrolmen's Benevolent Association of the City of New York, Inc., Detectives' Endowment Association, Inc., NYPD Captains Endowment Association and Lieutenants Benevolent Association of the City of New York, Inc., SENT.[1052423] [13-3088] 2013-09-28 03:38:18 b53f5866a66704acdae9ac629abe80c0389d5957
2013-09-27 105 0 MOTION, to file document, on behalf of Appellant Sergeants Benevolent Association in 13-3088, 13-3461, FILED. Service date 09/27/2013 by CM/ECF. [1053477] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
105 1 T-1080 2013-09-28 03:40:02 e772efba53820e260dfaf9bcec868e40c2172dde
105 2 Supporting Document 2013-09-28 03:39:29 56bf6ed4ec203a801fb14735d1b63638acd53483
105 3 Supporting Document 2013-09-28 03:40:28 0280c29f98528cd6e4bb1a540a586700fa7cdf95
2013-09-27 106 0 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS AMICUS COUNSEL, on behalf of Movants Patrolmen's Benevolent Association of the City of New York, Inc., Detectives Endowment Association, Police Department, City of New York, Inc., Lieutenants Benevolent Association of the City of New York, Inc. and Captains' Endowment Association of New York, FILED. Service date 09/27/2013 by CM/ECF. [1053498] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]--[Edited 09/30/2013 by DE] 2013-09-28 03:43:03 e3d14be7981ba6814be6daf096eae01128bc4a35
2013-09-27 107 0 MOTION TO FILE AMICUS CURIAE BRIEF, on behalf of Movants Patrolmen's Benevolent Association of the City of New York, Inc., Detectives Endowment Association, Police Department, City of New York, Inc., Lieutenants Benevolent Association of the City of New York, Inc. and Captains' Endowment Association of New York, FILED. Service date09/27/2013 by CM/ECF.[1053499] [13-3088]--[Edited 10/01/2013 by JW]
107 1 Motion for Leave to File as Amicus FILED 2013-09-28 03:42:23 e7c5b8aa2e7cf42d5e7e6dd5929176d0d8fe0331
107 2 Supporting Document 2013-09-28 03:42:51 dd7b433088ea30f718b31bf518871ad0901a4b57
107 3 Supporting Document 2013-09-28 03:44:53 dd30a8d69216fc5431bd7ea865651523b5a44160
2013-09-30 108 0 CAMP CONFERENCE ORDER VACATED, Scheduled Date of Conference: 10/21/2013, Start Time: 10:30 AM, endorsed by Vidya Kurella, FILED.[1053531] [13-3088]
2013-09-30 114 0 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS AMICUS COUNSEL, on behalf of Movant Michael B. Mukasey and Rudolph W. Giuliani, FILED. Service date 09/30/2013 by CM/ECF. [1054586] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]--[Edited 10/01/2013 by JW] 2013-10-01 11:45:45 f2f8886174036a0ec8360ec1313d7df462c72d33
2013-09-30 115 0 MOTION TO FILE AMICUS CURIAE BRIEF, on behalf of Movant Michael B. Mukasey and Rudolph W. Giuliani, FILED. Service date09/30/2013 by CM/ECF.[1054588] [13-3088]--[Edited 10/01/2013 by JW]
115 1 Motion for Leave to File as Amicus FILED 2013-10-01 11:44:29 be172d75e0f2bada65e760a49f9433fea2eacec4
115 2 Supporting Document 2013-10-01 11:44:43 9cef9f6cad7e05873bf7a887c62fb7c31781c0f8
115 3 Supporting Document 2013-10-01 11:46:22 75229529a842f3c3abd3ae0abc8d44dded4540ab
2013-10-01 121 0 ACKNOWLEDGMENT AND NOTICE OF APPEARANCE, on behalf of Appellant Sergeants Benevolent Association in 13-3088, 13-3461, FILED. Service date 10/01/2013 by CM/ECF.[1055805] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-10-02 122 0 FRAP 26.1 CORPORATE DISCLOSURE STATEMENT, on behalf of Movant Captains' Endowment Association of New York, Detectives Endowment Association, Police Department, City of New York, Inc., Lieutenants Benevolent Association of the City of New York, Inc. and Patrolmen's Benevolent Association of the City of New York, Inc., FILED. Service date 10/02/2013 by CM/ECF.[1056201] [13-3088]
2013-10-03 126 0 ARGUMENT NOTICE, to attorneys/parties, TRANSMITTED.[1057680] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524] 2013-10-03 13:37:33 2c2d48a7733a315c5fd1cb11da721629a373dce9
2013-10-03 130 0 **REVISED**ARGUMENT NOTICE, to attorneys/parties, TRANSMITTED.[1057782] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524] 2013-10-03 14:45:52 9f149a20cf18ef245361989e563f65bd83acda64
2013-10-03 132 0 LETTER, requesting adjournment of oral argument, on behalf of Appellee Lalit Clarkson, Deon Dennis, David Floyd and David Ourlicht, RECEIVED. Service date 10/03/2013 by CM/ECF.[1058007] [13-3088]--[Edited 10/04/2013 by JW] 2013-10-03 16:20:38 5c51494a723425e692a4a39a5faf5734c5268780
2013-10-04 135 0 LETTER, responding to Appellees' letter, on behalf of Appellant City of New York, RECEIVED. Service date 10/04/2013 by CM/ECF.[1058386] [13-3088]--[Edited 10/04/2013 by JW] 2013-10-05 08:29:55 42690f0e9467bad433a88fa54cd2bc7f521304fc
2013-10-07 142 0 DEFECTIVE DOCUMENT, motion[141], on behalf of Appellee Lalit Clarkson, Deon Dennis, David Floyd and David Ourlicht, FILED.[1059950] [13-3088] 2013-10-07 23:32:08 eb8187cade7722efd3b848d482af8f9ea4936282
2013-10-07 143 0 OPPOSITION TO MOTION to dismiss [76], on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 10/07/2013 by CM/ECF, hand delivery. [1059961][143] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524] 2013-10-07 23:32:30 393f12ffa468e83db685d513e7816f4edfe8af55
2013-10-07 144 0 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS AMICUS COUNSEL, on behalf of Movant The Office of the Public Advocate for the City of New York, FILED. Service date 10/07/2013 by CM/ECF. [1059969] [13-3088]--[Edited 10/16/2013 by JW] 2013-10-07 23:34:23 73100c61a5f033adf45d0264d579573f3b1719df
2013-10-07 145 0 MOTION, to file oversized brief, on behalf of Appellee Lalit Clarkson, Deon Dennis, David Floyd and David Ourlicht, FILED. Service date 10/07/2013 by CM/ECF. [1060053] [13-3088]
145 1 Motion to File Oversized Response to Motion for Stay 2013-10-07 23:35:16 ae0b86429898823d198ff90d507253475a39b9ba
145 2 Charney Declaration in Support of Motion to File Oversized Response 2013-10-07 23:36:17 d02250fefaac0d4cfbefee87e0f19cb30f437dd1
145 3 Exhibits A-Z to Charney Declaration
145 4 Exhibits AA-MM to Charney Declaration
145 5 Memorandum of Law in Opposition to Motion to Stay 2013-10-07 23:38:06 b6bdaddf4856a12091c307db66ae7f7aee518c46
2013-10-07 146 0 OPPOSITION TO MOTION to stay [72], on behalf of Appellee Lalit Clarkson, Deon Dennis, David Floyd and David Ourlicht, FILED. Service date 10/07/2013 by CM/ECF. [1060073][146] [13-3088]
146 1 Charney Declaration in Opposition to Motion for a Stay
146 2 Exhibits A-Z to Charney Declaration
146 3 Exhibits AA-MM to Charney Declaration
146 4 Memorandum of Law in Opposition to Motion for a Stay
2013-10-07 147 0 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE, for Memorandum of law in opposition to motion to dismiss appeal, on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, FILED. Service date 10/07/2013 by hand delivery.[1060350] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524] 2013-10-08 11:24:17 3ea0d0582dd8d19bc74fe17b95e1df62b1efc89e
2013-10-08 156 0 ARGUMENT NOTICE, to attorneys/parties, TRANSMITTED.[1060788] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524] 2013-10-08 11:25:31 e79e0b9a340a257ca9bf8f2e9cf6d000810bd47c
2013-10-10 157 0 MOTION ORDER, referring motion to dismiss [76] filed by Appellee David Floyd, Lalit Clarkson, Deon Dennis and David Ourlicht in 13-3088, FILED. [1062756][157] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524] 2013-10-10 10:27:14 9c98dab8dbefd72651b736f61d636cf82ecb32c5
2013-10-10 158 0 MOTION ORDER, granting motion to file memorandum in support of the Appellant's stay motion [105] filed by Appellant Sergeants Benevolent Association in 13-3088, FILED. [1062771][158] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-10-10 159 0 MOTION ORDER, granting non-parties Patrolmen's Benevolent Association, et al motion to file a memorandum of law as amicus curiae [107] in 13-3088, FILED. [1062775][159] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-10-10 160 0 MOTION ORDER, granting Non-parties Michael B. Mukasey and Rudolph W. Giuliani, motion to file amicus curiae brief [115] in 13-3088, FILED. [1062792][160] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-10-11 162 0 **REVISED**ARGUMENT NOTICE, to attorneys/parties, TRANSMITTED.[1063791] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-10-11 168 0 **2nd REVISED**ARGUMENT NOTICE, to attorneys/parties, TRANSMITTED.[1064579] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524] 2013-10-17 00:57:15 d55b2cebc10fd8c15dc8c12773cc59cde26e4ef0
2013-10-14 169 0 SUPPLEMENTARY PAPERS TO MOTION [72], on behalf of Appellant Sergeants Benevolent Association in 13-3088, 13-3461, FILED. Service date 10/14/2013 by CM/ECF.[1064889][169] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-10-15 170 0 REPLY TO OPPOSITION [143], on behalf of Appellee Lalit Clarkson, Deon Dennis, David Floyd and David Ourlicht, FILED. Service date 10/15/2013 by CM/ECF.[1065743][170] [13-3088] 2013-10-17 00:57:39 aa58bf048af9b35885d122984ee35e3b94643b7d
2013-10-15 171 0 MOTION, to vacate previous order, on behalf of Appellee Lalit Clarkson, Deon Dennis, David Floyd and David Ourlicht, FILED. Service date 10/15/2013 by CM/ECF. [1066042] [13-3088]--[Edited 10/15/2013 by JW]
171 1 Motion to Vacate Prior Order 2013-10-17 01:00:05 df6c5230114610d3b4ca61fc1ce636c75e5739e8
171 2 Declaration in Support of Motion to Vacate Prior Order
171 3 Memorandum of Law in Support of Motion to Vacate Prior Order
2013-10-15 174 0 SUPPLEMENTARY PAPERS TO MOTION [72], on behalf of Movant Rudolph W. Giuliani and Michael B. Mukasey, FILED. Service date 10/15/2013 by CM/ECF.[1066201][174] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-10-15 175 0 MOTION TO FILE AMICUS CURIAE BRIEF, on behalf of Movant The Office of the Public Advocate for the City of New York, FILED. Service date10/15/2013 by CM/ECF.[1066232] [13-3088]--[Edited 10/16/2013 by JW]
175 1 Motion for Leave to File as Amicus FILED
175 2 Motion for Leave to File an Amicus Curiae Memorandum of Law
175 3 Memorandum of Law of the Office of the Public Advocate for the City of New York 2013-10-29 15:26:56 b9481fe059b7669bf84ab5ddd9b8749523611154
10/15/2013 178 0 SUPPLEMENTARY PAPERS TO MOTION [107], on behalf of Movant Captains' Endowment Association of New York, Detectives Endowment Association, Police Department, City of New York, Inc., Lieutenants Benevolent Association of the City of New York, Inc. and Patrolmen's Benevolent Association of the City of New York, Inc., FILED. Service date 10/15/2013 by CM/ECF.[1066244][178] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-10-15 179 0 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS AMICUS COUNSEL, on behalf of Movant Bill Lann Lee, FILED. Service date 10/15/2013 by CM/ECF. [1066274] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]--[Edited 10/16/2013 by JW] 2013-10-17 00:59:57 09e6851d349667b055941c6f323aeb3b44244849
2013-10-15 181 0 MOTION TO FILE AMICUS CURIAE BRIEF, on behalf of Movant Bill Lann Lee, FILED. Service date10/15/2013 by CM/ECF.[1066278] [13-3088]--[Edited 10/16/2013 by JW]
181 1 Motion for Leave to File as Amicus FILED 2013-10-17 01:02:04 605e46bfdd3ca4308e31c113afd5304ccc6d683b
181 2 Unopposed Motion to File as Amicus 2013-10-17 01:01:45 4b82ffadb11b3bc71d74e7d803f4b96f55f82db7
181 3 Brief Amicus Curiae of Bill Lan Lee
2013-10-16 187 0 DEFECTIVE DOCUMENTS, notice of appearances[177], [176], on behalf of Movant Bill Lann Lee, FILED.[1067056] [13-3088]
2013-10-16 189 0 DEFECTIVE DOCUMENT, notice of appearance as amicus counsel[180], on behalf of Movant Bill Lann Lee, FILED.[1067060] [13-3088]
10/16/2013 193 0 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS ADDITIONAL COUNSEL, on behalf of Movant Bill Lann Lee in 13-3524, FILED. Service date 10/16/2013 by CM/ECF. [1067328] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-10-16 194 0 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS ADDITIONAL COUNSEL, on behalf of Movant Bill Lann Lee in 13-3524, FILED. Service date 10/16/2013 by CM/ECF. [1067398] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-10-17 200 0 DEFECTIVE DOCUMENT, supplementary papers to motion[178], on behalf of Movant Captains' Endowment Association of New York, Detectives Endowment Association, Police Department, City of New York, Inc., Lieutenants Benevolent Association of the City of New York, Inc. and Patrolmen's Benevolent Association of the City of New York, Inc., FILED.[1068054] [13-3088]
2013-10-17 201 0 MOTION ORDER, granting Bill Lann Lee motion to file amicus curiae brief [181] in 13-3088, FILED. [1068072][201] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-10-17 202 0 MOTION ORDER, granting The Office of the Public Advocate of New York City motion to file amicus curiae brief [175] in 13-3088,FILED. [1068080][202] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-10-17 204 0 SUPPLEMENTARY PAPERS TO OPPOSITION[146], on behalf of Movant Bill Lann Lee in 13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 10/17/2013 by CM/ECF.[1068213][204] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]--[Edited 10/21/2013 by JW]
2013-10-17 205 0 SUPPLEMENTARY PAPERS TO OPPOSITION[146], on behalf of Movant The Office of the Public Advocate for the City of New York, FILED. Service date 10/17/2013 by CM/ECF.[1068500][205] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]--[Edited 10/21/2013 by JW]
2013-10-17 206 0 REPLY TO OPPOSITION [146], on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 10/17/2013 by CM/ECF.[1068840][206] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-10-18 208 0 MOTION ORDER, granting motion to vacate order to the extent that the panel determining the stay motion will hear argument[171], filed by Appellee David Floyd, Lalit Clarkson, Deon Dennis and David Ourlicht in 13-3088, FILED. [1069099][208] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-10-18 212 0 SUPPLEMENTARY PAPERS TO MOTION [72], on behalf of Movant Captains' Endowment Association of New York, Detectives Endowment Association, Police Department, City of New York, Inc., Lieutenants Benevolent Association of the City of New York, Inc. and Patrolmen's Benevolent Association of the City of New York, Inc., FILED. Service date 10/18/2013 by CM/ECF.[1069811][212] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-10-22 219 0 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS ADDITIONAL COUNSEL, on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, FILED. Service date 10/22/2013 by CM/ECF. [1071873] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-10-22 222 0 LETTER, requesting argument time, on behalf of Appellant Sergeants Benevolent Association, RECEIVED. Service date 10/22/2013 by CM/ECF.[1072649] [13-3088]--[Edited 10/23/2013 by JW]
2013-10-25 228 0 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS ADDITIONAL COUNSEL, on behalf of Appellant Sergeants Benevolent Association in 13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 10/25/2013 by CM/ECF. [1075676] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-10-30 233 0 DEFECTIVE DOCUMENT, FRAP 28(j) LETTER[231], on behalf of Appellant City of New York, FILED.[1079569] [13-3088]
2013-10-30 234 0 LETTER, in response to an inquiry during yesterday’s oral argument, on behalf of Appellant City of New York, RECEIVED. Service date 10/30/2013 by CM/ECF.[1079590] [13-3088]--[Edited 10/30/2013 by JW] 2013-10-30 20:57:18 4cfcdfc9a144a9809933d3d85b884dd97f9b8012
2013-10-31 237 0 LETTER, on behalf of Appellee Lalit Clarkson, Deon Dennis, David Floyd and David Ourlicht, RECEIVED. Service date 10/31/2013 by CM/ECF.[1080383] [13-3088] 2013-10-31 16:08:35 339998df2cbdecd280d4f6cb684006d137c63c47
2013-10-31 238 0 LETTER, on behalf of Appellant City of New York, RECEIVED. Service date 10/31/2013 by CM/ECF.[1080391] [13-3088] 2013-10-31 16:09:15 24592d08a0988bbde0db2db468bf57d931930cb5
2013-10-31 241 0 LETTER, on behalf of Appellee Lalit Clarkson, Deon Dennis, David Floyd and David Ourlicht, RECEIVED. Service date 10/31/2013 by CM/ECF.[1080889] [13-3088] 2013-10-31 16:12:17 a1dcd738be8d5fa00987a7910734df374e7441ee
10/31/2013 243 0 CERTIFIED MANDATE ORDER, dated 10/31/2013, to SDNY (NEW YORK CITY), ISSUED.[1080946] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524] 2013-10-31 15:39:25 4bb00416e880f00b46e563484201af4df8d96c88
2013-10-31 244 0 ORDER, dated 10/31/2013, remanding the case to the district court, by JMW, JAC, BDP, FILED.[1080991] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524] 2013-10-31 16:07:08 d521abed23747df4f4fb9c79595afce66aa10e48
2013-10-31 245 0 CERTIFIED MANDATE ORDER, dated 10/31/2013, to SDNY (NEW YORK CITY), ISSUED.[1080994] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524] 2013-10-31 16:05:14 3c0fccb00a82f3365dc54f454ba42d655a2dff81
2013-10-31 246 0 CORRECTED ORDER, dated 10/31/2013, remanding the case to the district court, FILED.[1081109] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-10-31 247 0 CORRECTED CERTIFIED MANDATE ORDER, dated 10/31/2013, to SDNY (NEW YORK CITY), ISSUED.[1081116] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-11-04 249 0 REQUEST FOR ARGUMENT CD from WESTLAW, with fee, RECEIVED.[1082766] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524] 2013-11-06 07:46:05 44ba7a92dd79c8f7f004ad5efc3ed974d77e8731
11/06/2013 251 0 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS AMICUS COUNSEL, on behalf of, <EDIT by Clerk's Office> , FILED. Service date 11/06/2013 by CM/ECF. [1086018] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-11-07 252 0 MOTION, to intervene, on behalf of Movant Captains' Endowment Association of New York, Detectives Endowment Association, Police Department, City of New York, Inc., Lieutenants Benevolent Association of the City of New York, Inc. and Patrolmen's Benevolent Association of the City of New York, Inc., FILED. Service date 11/07/2013 by CM/ECF. [1086162] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
252 1 Motion FILED
252 2 Supporting Document - Memorandum of Law in Support
252 3 Supporting Document - Declaration of Steven A. Engel
2013-11-07 258 0 DEFECTIVE DOCUMENT, notice of appearance as amicus counsel[251], on behalf of Movant Shira A. Scheindlin, FILED.[1086911] [13-3088] 2013-11-08 03:16:46 c98830f5332bc601e1b90afe820117f3d02bfc8a
11/08/2013 260 0 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS AMICUS COUNSEL, on behalf of, <EDIT by Clerk's Office> , FILED. Service date 11/08/2013 by CM/ECF. [1088102] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524] 2013-11-08 13:04:49 5150251319f90db3c767e5fac9cb603ae5aba61b
2013-11-08 261 0 MOTION TO FILE AMICUS CURIAE BRIEF, on behalf of Movant Shira A. Scheindlin, FILED. Service date11/08/2013 by CM/ECF.[1088212] [13-3088]--[Edited 11/12/2013 by JW]
261 1 Motion for Leave to File as Amicus FILED 2013-11-09 09:10:13 94d1a69a8ee833429aafacdb53714e89fe3c3198
261 2 Exhibit 1
261 3 Exhibit 2
261 4 Exhibit 3
261 5 Exhibit 4
261 6 Exhibit 5
261 7 Exhibit 6
261 8 Exhibit 7
2013-11-08 262 0 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS ADDITIONAL COUNSEL, on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 11/08/2013 by CM/ECF. [1088219] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524] 2013-11-08 14:04:41 78590ce1ac8ada026ddaa1007ef2ea905568a502
2013-11-08 263 0 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS AMICUS COUNSEL, on behalf of Movant Shira A. Scheindlin, FILED. Service date 11/08/2013 by CM/ECF. [1088294] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]--[Edited 11/12/2013 by JW] 2013-11-08 14:51:25 106034f672851f9f75d6aea6a0fbe952b1649ca5
2013-11-08 264 0 LETTER, informing the Court that the exhibits in the motion have been corrected, on behalf of Movant Shira A. Scheindlin, RECEIVED. Service date 11/08/2013 by CM/ECF.[1088400] [13-3088]--[Edited 11/12/2013 by JW] 2013-11-09 09:03:10 eba3a91fab25a894d2bbd7697a765fa8460c55d7
2013-11-09 265 0 MOTION, to modify the stay order, on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 11/09/2013 by CM/ECF. [1088562] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]--[Edited 11/12/2013 by JW] 2013-11-09 00:21:03 ea880bd0c1e1dbcf74e70a7610fbbe5ee97ec69a
2013-11-10 266 0 LETTER, requesting the Court to withdraw a portion of the panel's order, on behalf of Movant Shira A. Scheindlin, RECEIVED. Service date 11/10/2013 by CM/ECF.[1088577] [13-3088]--[Edited 11/12/2013 by JW] 2013-11-10 14:32:19 3eab39b4282e66f99cc524025bec5a2fe53baf8a
2013-11-11 267 0 PETITION FOR REHEARING/REHEARING EN BANC, on behalf of Appellee Lalit Clarkson, Deon Dennis, David Floyd and David Ourlicht, FILED. Service date 11/11/2013 by CM/ECF.[1088586] [13-3088]
267 1 Motion for Reconsideration by the En Banc Court of the October 31, 2013 Mandate 2013-11-12 09:49:31 25deb4e0d2ca9903d33e6c8010c36a23195998f4
267 2 Plaintiffs-Appellees' Memorandum of Law in Support of Motion for Reconsideration
267 3 Borchetta Declaration in Support of Motion
267 4 Exhibit A to Borchetta Declaration
267 5 Exhibit B to Borchetta Declaration
267 6 Exhibit C to Borchetta Declaration
2013-11-11 268 0 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS AMICUS COUNSEL, on behalf of Movant Michael B. Mukasey and Rudolph W. Giuliani, FILED. Service date 11/11/2013 by CM/ECF. [1088593] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]--[Edited 11/12/2013 by JW] 2013-11-12 09:50:43 1e180cde58ce7c252eaaff0bf5434e101d8a021f
2013-11-12 276 0 LETTER, in response to the Appellant's motion, on behalf of Appellee Lalit Clarkson, Deon Dennis, David Floyd and David Ourlicht, RECEIVED. Service date 11/12/2013 by CM/ECF.[1089370] [13-3088]--[Edited 11/12/2013 by JW] 2013-11-12 14:35:37 4ff1d670ba420f65a5d34e482ce0792be26810a0
2013-11-12 277 0 LETTER, in response to the Appellee's letter, on behalf of Appellant City of New York, RECEIVED. Service date 11/12/2013 by CM/ECF.[1089554] [13-3088]--[Edited 11/12/2013 by JW] 2013-11-12 14:54:27 c09bffdf0153e0030e8f57dc654bddb15dd764a5
2013-11-12 281 0 LETTER, voicing concerns about the timing of filings, on behalf of Movant Captains' Endowment Association of New York, Detectives Endowment Association, Police Department, City of New York, Inc., Lieutenants Benevolent Association of the City of New York, Inc. and Patrolmen's Benevolent Association of the City of New York, Inc., RECEIVED. Service date 11/12/2013 by CM/ECF.[1090011] [13-3088]--[Edited 11/13/2013 by JW] 2013-11-12 19:31:15 379c7ba61078538bb30573f78cde543501132931
2013-11-12 282 0 MOTION, to intervene, on behalf of Appellant Sergeants Benevolent Association in 13-3088, 13-3461, FILED. Service date 11/12/2013 by CM/ECF. [1090032] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
282 1 Motion FILED 2013-11-12 19:34:13 00e637f2e01ddd7d88b0f7477dd4518ebac7cf14
282 2 Supporting Document
282 3 Memorandum of Law In Support of Motion
2013-11-12 283 0 CORRECTED MOTION, to intervene, on behalf of Appellant Sergeants Benevolent Association in 13-3088, 13-3461, FILED. Service date 11/12/2013 by CM/ECF. [1090065] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]--[Edited 11/13/2013 by JW]
283 1 Motion FILED
283 2 Supporting Document
283 3 Memorandum of Law in Support
2013-11-13 290 0 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS AMICUS COUNSEL, on behalf of Movants Stacy Caplow, Erwin Chemerinsky, Brett Dignam, Laura K. Donohue, Eric M. Freedman, Amanda Frost, Brandon L. Garrett, Jamal Greene, Jonathan Hafetz, Aziz Huq, Karl Manheim, Carlin Meyer, James Sample, Adam Nathan Steinman, Colin Starger, Kendall Thomas and Stephen Vladeck, FILED. Service date 11/13/2013 by CM/ECF. [1090780] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]--[Edited 11/20/2013 by JW]
2013-11-13 291 0 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS AMICUS COUNSEL, on behalf of Movants Stacy Caplow, Erwin Chemerinsky, Brett Dignam, Laura K. Donohue, Eric M. Freedman, Amanda Frost, Brandon L. Garrett, Jamal Greene, Jonathan Hafetz, Aziz Huq, Karl Manheim, Carlin Meyer, James Sample, Adam Nathan Steinman, Colin Starger, Kendall Thomas and Stephen Vladeck, FILED. Service date 11/13/2013 by CM/ECF. [1090793] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]--[Edited 11/20/2013 by JW]
2013-11-13 292 0 OPPOSITION TO MOTION for rehearing en banc [267], to file amicus curiae brief [261], on behalf of Movant Captains' Endowment Association of New York, Detectives Endowment Association, Police Department, City of New York, Inc., Lieutenants Benevolent Association of the City of New York, Inc. and Patrolmen's Benevolent Association of the City of New York, Inc., FILED. Service date 11/13/2013 by CM/ECF. [1090944][292] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524] 2013-11-13 14:02:39 fc0f92bd5eae3b87360be75b9915c97e77b18520
2013-11-13 293 0 OPPOSITION TO MOTION for rehearing en banc [267], to file amicus curiae brief [261], on behalf of Movant Rudolph W. Giuliani and Michael B. Mukasey, FILED. Service date 11/13/2013 by CM/ECF. [1090964][293] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524] 2013-11-13 14:08:07 a76f690fe90c698fd5532d868f48b7b00fc4c628
2013-11-13 294 0 OPPOSITION TO MOTION to file amicus curiae brief [261], for rehearing en banc [267], on behalf of Appellant Sergeants Benevolent Association in 13-3088, 13-3461, FILED. Service date 11/13/2013 by CM/ECF. [1090980][294] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-11-13 295 0 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS AMICUS COUNSEL, on behalf of Movants Stacy Caplow, Erwin Chemerinsky, Brett Dignam, Laura K. Donohue, Eric M. Freedman, Amanda Frost, Brandon L. Garrett, Jamal Greene, Jonathan Hafetz, Aziz Huq, Karl Manheim, Carlin Meyer, James Sample, Adam Nathan Steinman, Colin Starger, Kendall Thomas and Stephen Vladeck, FILED. Service date 11/13/2013 by CM/ECF. [1090984] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]--[Edited 11/20/2013 by JW] 2013-11-15 18:10:35 5a12684d7712307b24c17aa443c9499aef8fc82a
2013-11-13 296 0 MOTION TO FILE AMICUS CURIAE BRIEF, on behalf of Movants Stacy Caplow, Erwin Chemerinsky, Brett Dignam, Laura K. Donohue, Eric M. Freedman, Amanda Frost, Brandon L. Garrett, Jamal Greene, Jonathan Hafetz, Aziz Huq, Karl Manheim, Carlin Meyer, James Sample, Adam Nathan Steinman, Colin Starger, Kendall Thomas and Stephen Vladeck, FILED. Service date11/13/2013 by CM/ECF.[1090993] [13-3088]--[Edited 11/20/2013 by JW]
296 1 Motion for Leave to File as Amicus FILED
296 2 Proposed Amicus Brief
2013-11-13 297 0 OPPOSITION TO PETITION FOR REHEARING/REHEARING EN BANC for rehearing en banc [267], to file amicus curiae brief [261], on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 11/13/2013 by CM/ECF. [1091010][297] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524] 2013-11-13 14:29:03 9579e0a9ce6b9ebe4977adaf804a5cc0baec004f
2013-11-13 298 0 MOTION TO FILE AMICUS CURIAE BRIEF, on behalf of Non-Party Filer(s), FILED. Service date11/13/2013 by CM/ECF.[1091022] [13-3088]
298 1 Motion for Leave to File as Amicus FILED 2013-11-13 14:31:08 9fea1ab5cd94b20d7c1ccaa2ecb3a8c2b11dc6be
298 2 Supporting Document 2013-11-13 14:33:19 84ef349f784090d14ce77b384a5245a233ae23b0
298 3 Proposed Amicus Brief 2013-11-13 14:34:30 a2f86e66d94f7c7a4e597e8d4ab1af02cd123695
2013-11-13 299 0 MOTION TO FILE AMICUS CURIAE BRIEF, on behalf of Non-Party Filer(s), FILED. Service date11/13/2012 by CM/ECF.[1091121] [13-3088] 2013-11-13 15:07:22 b08c1afcd5e6fa1426d2c26f8fb04954e1d2d9ff
2013-11-13 301 0 MOTION ORDER, denying motion for leave to appear[261] on behalf of Movant Shira A. Scheindlin, in 13-3088, by JMW, JAC, BDP, FILED. [1091474][301] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524] 2013-11-13 17:43:58 5367496d46d6708fc8353d3f87210d18f89ddc0d
2013-11-13 303 0 NON-DISPOSITIVE PER CURIAM OPINION re: MOTION, FILED.[1091492] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]--[Edited 11/13/2013 by JW]
2013-11-13 304 0 NON-DISPOSITIVE PER CURIAM OPINION, FILED.[1091499] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]--[Edited 11/13/2013 by JW]
2013-11-13 305 0 CERTIFIED NON-DISPOSITIVE PER CURIAM OPINION re: MOTION, dated 11/13/2013, to SDNY, ISSUED.[1091538] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]--[Edited 11/13/2013 by JW]
2013-11-13 306 0 CERTIFIED NON-DISPOSITIVE PER CURIAM OPINION, dated 11/13/2013, to SDNY, ISSUED.[1091542] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-11-18 309 0 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS AMICUS COUNSEL, on behalf of Movant Robert J. Cindrich, David H. Coar, William Royal Furgeson Jr., Nancy Gertner, Richard J. Holwell, Stanley Sporkin, Anita Bernstein, Carol Buckler, Monroe Freedman, Bennett L. Gershman, Bruce Green, Mark I. Harrison, Richard Klein, Myles V. Lynk, Peter Margulies, Lawrence Raful, Deborah L. Rhode, Rebecca Roiphe and W. Bradley Wendel, FILED. Service date 11/18/2013 by CM/ECF. [1095054] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]--[Edited 11/20/2013 by JW] 2013-11-18 16:25:09 dec638fd5b844bc40a6bb4664d06dd662e185399
2013-11-18 310 0 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS AMICUS COUNSEL, on behalf of Movant Robert J. Cindrich, David H. Coar, William Royal Furgeson Jr., Nancy Gertner, Richard J. Holwell, Stanley Sporkin, Anita Bernstein, Carol Buckler, Monroe Freedman, Bennett L. Gershman, Bruce Green, Mark I. Harrison, Richard Klein, Myles V. Lynk, Peter Margulies, Lawrence Raful, Deborah L. Rhode, Rebecca Roiphe and W. Bradley Wendel, FILED. Service date 11/18/2013 by CM/ECF. [1095169] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]--[Edited 11/20/2013 by JW] 2013-11-18 16:27:30 62c66161afd29a5fe62526a5e115c43e4ddaab10
2013-11-18 311 0 MOTION TO FILE AMICUS CURIAE BRIEF, on behalf of Non-Party Filer(s), FILED. Service date11/18/2013 by CM/ECF.[1095282] [13-3088] 2013-11-18 16:30:04 4478446087e0b22cdb2e7127010c1e142659305a
2013-11-18 312 0 MOTION TO FILE AMICUS CURIAE BRIEF, on behalf of Movant Robert J. Cindrich, David H. Coar, William Royal Furgeson Jr., Nancy Gertner, Richard J. Holwell, Stanley Sporkin, Anita Bernstein, Carol Buckler, Monroe Freedman, Bennett L. Gershman, Bruce Green, Mark I. Harrison, Richard Klein, Myles V. Lynk, Peter Margulies, Lawrence Raful, Deborah L. Rhode, Rebecca Roiphe and W. Bradley Wendel, FILED. Service date11/18/2013 by CM/ECF.[1095635] [13-3088]--[Edited 11/20/2013 by JW] 2013-11-18 17:56:17 0c1716fe306269fd2ab79d87ff3a5dee9bbc0dcb
2013-11-18 313 0 AMICUS BRIEF, on behalf of Movant Robert J. Cindrich, David H. Coar, William Royal Furgeson Jr., Nancy Gertner, Richard J. Holwell, Stanley Sporkin, Anita Bernstein, Carol Buckler, Monroe Freedman, Bennett L. Gershman, Bruce Green, Mark I. Harrison, Richard Klein, Myles V. Lynk, Peter Margulies, Lawrence Raful, Deborah L. Rhode, Rebecca Roiphe and W. Bradley Wendel, FILED. Service date 11/18/2013 by CM/ECF. [1095636] [13-3088]--[Edited 11/20/2013 by JW]
2013-11-18 314 0 MOTION, for rehearing en banc, on behalf of Appellee Lalit Clarkson, Deon Dennis, David Floyd and David Ourlicht, FILED. Service date 11/18/2013 by CM/ECF. [1095657] [13-3088]
314 1 Supplemental Motion for Reconsideration By the En Banc Court FILED
314 2 Suppmental Motion Supporting Document
314 3 Decalaration of Jenn Rolnick Borchetta Supporting Document
314 4 Exhibit A to Borchetta Declaration Supporting Document
314 5 Exhibit B to Borchetta Declaration Supporting Document
2013-11-19 317 0 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS ADDITIONAL COUNSEL, on behalf of Appellee Lalit Clarkson, Deon Dennis, David Floyd and David Ourlicht in 13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 11/19/2013 by CM/ECF. [1096316] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524] 2013-11-19 18:02:02 1f2a491d3ac38a3dc3e70504b89245ab73cec442
2013-11-19 319 0 ORDER, dated 11/19/2013, granting Appellees' request for an extension of time in which to file a response to the 11/07/2013 motion to intervene, FILED.[1096834] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524] 2013-11-19 18:03:42 e856e8f959ec7c98d36b7b590a2941a6b422fc19
2013-11-20 321 0 MOTION, to extend time, on behalf of Appellee Lalit Clarkson, Deon Dennis, David Floyd and David Ourlicht, FILED. Service date 11/20/2013 by CM/ECF. [1097777] [13-3088]
321 1 Motion FILED 2013-11-20 16:20:32 2ed55bd6eb54d3c6ed93a633b9c1963b9639399f
321 2 Supporting Document 2013-11-22 07:15:54 6e9f4c8ae51dd4162eebf2e38513a77bee6b6813
2013-11-20 324 0 OPPOSITION TO MOTION to extend time [321], on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, FILED. Service date 11/20/2013 by CM/ECF. [1097919][324] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524] 2013-11-20 18:33:43 06d001c921f7439483841b8dfdf3b78097409ef1
2013-11-20 325 0 LETTER, responding to the Appellant's opposition, on behalf of Movant Shira A. Scheindlin, RECEIVED. Service date 11/20/2013 by CM/ECF.[1097931] [13-3088]--[Edited 11/21/2013 by JW] 2013-11-20 20:45:11 83eafbb7dcddbc47c82ce6a1c8deeb95a5077e38
2013-11-21 332 0 MOTION ORDER, granting in part motion to adjourn deadline to file opposition[321] filed by Appellee David Floyd, Lalit Clarkson, Deon Dennis and David Ourlicht in 13-3088, by JAC, FILED. [1098801][332] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]--[Edited 11/21/2013 by JW] 2013-11-21 18:37:15 608d306f80cb749a9c43dd96efaea960f4b274b8
2013-11-22 333 0 MOTION ORDER, denying motion for modification of the stay order [265] filed by Appellant City of New York, and denying motion for leave to oppose the City's motion[299] filed by Movant Shira Scheindlin, by JMW, JAC, BDP, C.JJ., FILED. [1099132][333] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524] 2013-11-22 09:43:23 7df9a9e836e241f28ab8dac358c594007a854e24
2013-11-22 334 0 NON-DISPOSITIVE PER CURIAM OPINION re: MOTIONS, FILED.[1099146] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-11-22 335 0 CERTIFIED NON-DISPOSITIVE PER CURIAM OPINION re: MOTIONS, dated 11/22/2013, to SDNY, ISSUED.[1099161] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-11-25 336 0 SUPPLEMENTARY PAPERS TO PETITION FOR REHEARING EN BANC [263], on behalf of Movant Shira A. Scheindlin in 13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 11/25/2013 by CM/ECF.[1100482][336] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-11-25 337 0 REQUEST FOR ARGUMENT CD from L. VERGUIZAS with fee, RECEIVED.[1101066] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-11-25 338 0 MOTION ORDER, abeyance of motion for rehearing en banc [314] filed by Appellee David Floyd, Lalit Clarkson, Deon Dennis and David Ourlicht; abeyance of motion to intervene [282] filed by Appellant Sergeants Benevolent Association, FILED. [1101127][338] [13-3088] 2013-11-26 07:32:04 807ade24e1b844493672c9cb9b5ea12526e1507d
2013-11-25 339 0 OPPOSITION TO MOTION to intervene [252], to intervene [283], on behalf of Appellee Lalit Clarkson, Deon Dennis, David Floyd and David Ourlicht, FILED. Service date 11/25/2013 by CM/ECF. [1101169][339] [13-3088]
339 1 Plaintiffs-Appellees' Opposition to the Unions' Motions to Intervene FILED
339 2 Declaration of Darius Charney
339 3 Exhibit A
339 4 Exhibit B
339 5 Exhibit C
339 6 Exhibit D
339 7 Exhibit E
339 8 Exhibit F
339 9 Exhibit G
339 10 Exhibit H
339 11 Exhibit I
339 12 Exhibit J
339 13 Exhibit K
2013-12-04 340 0 ERRATA SHEET, for Non-Dispositive Per Curiam Opinion dated 11/22/2013, by JAC, FILED.[1106197] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524] 2013-12-05 03:40:35 5c52acba0399a7441609f0684a6401f4a3f3cd79
2013-12-05 342 0 REPLY TO OPPOSITION [339], on behalf of Movant Captains' Endowment Association of New York, Detectives Endowment Association, Police Department, City of New York, Inc., Lieutenants Benevolent Association of the City of New York, Inc. and Patrolmen's Benevolent Association of the City of New York, Inc., FILED. Service date 12/05/2013 by CM/ECF.[1108251][342] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
342 1 Reply to Opposition FILED 2013-12-05 18:15:10 25e3fbb4894509f3a35fcd86122315e2d8a77f4d
342 2 Supporting Document
2013-12-05 343 0 REQUEST FOR ARGUMENT CD from DLA PIPER with fee, RECEIVED.[1108262] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-05 344 0 REPLY TO OPPOSITION [339], on behalf of Appellant Sergeants Benevolent Association in 13-3088, 13-3461, FILED. Service date 12/05/2013 by CM/ECF.[1108289][344] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-10 345 0 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS ADDITIONAL COUNSEL, on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/10/2013 by CM/ECF. [1110885] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-10 347 0 BRIEF, on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/10/2013 by CM/ECF.[1111796] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 348 0 SPECIAL APPENDIX, on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by CM/ECF.[1112229] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 349 0 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS ADDITIONAL COUNSEL, on behalf of Movant Captains' Endowment Association of New York, Detectives Endowment Association, Police Department, City of New York, Inc., Lieutenants Benevolent Association of the City of New York, Inc. and Patrolmen's Benevolent Association of the City of New York, Inc. in 13-3088, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by CM/ECF. [1112888] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-17 351 0 LETTER, advising the Court attorney Borchetta is withdrawing her appearance, on behalf of Appellee Lalit Clarkson, Deon Dennis, David Floyd and David Ourlicht, RECEIVED. Service date 12/17/2013 by CM/ECF.[1116511] [13-3088]--[Edited 12/17/2013 by JW]
2013-12-11 353 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 1 of 88, (pp. 1-295), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117470] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 354 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 2 of 88, (pp. 296-576), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117474] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 355 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 3 of 88, (pp. 577-840), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117477] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 356 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 4 of 88, (pp. 841-1111), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117480] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 357 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 5 of 88, (pp. 1112-1307), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117484] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 358 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 6 of 88, (pp. 1308-1548), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117489] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 359 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 7 of 88, (pp. 1549-1785), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117493] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 360 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 8 of 88, (pp. 1786-2084), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117499] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 361 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 9 of 88, (pp. 2085-2330), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117500] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 362 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 10 of 88, (pp. 2331-2572), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117503] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 363 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 11 of 88, (pp. 2573-2789), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117505] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 364 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 12 of 88, (pp. 2790-3008), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117509] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 365 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 13 of 88, (pp. 3009-3233), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117510] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 366 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 14 of 88, (pp. 3234-3532), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117515] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 367 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 15 of 88, (pp. 3533-3782), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117519] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 368 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 16 of 88, (pp. 3783-4035), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117520] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 369 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 17 of 88, (pp. 4036-4292), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117552] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 370 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 18 of 88, (pp. 4293-4549), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117554] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 371 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 19 of 88, (pp. 4550-4726), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117560] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 372 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 20 of 88, (pp. 4727-4988), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117565] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 373 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 21 of 88, (pp. 4989-5248), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117568] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 374 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 22 of 88, (pp. 5249-5548), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117570] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 375 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 23 of 88, (pp. 5549-5848), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117573] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 376 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 24 of 88, (pp. 5849-6148), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117576] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 377 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 25 of 88, (pp. 6149-6448), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117581] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 378 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 26 of 88, (pp. 6449-6661), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117583] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 379 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 27 of 88, (pp. 6662-6902), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117586] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 380 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 28 of 88, (pp. 6903-7202), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117587] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 381 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 29 of 88, (pp. 7203-7500), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117590] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 382 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 30 of 88, (pp. 7501-7800), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117593] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 383 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 31 of 88, (pp. 7801-8098), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117599] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 384 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 32 of 88, (pp. 8099-8398), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117600] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 385 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 33 of 88, (pp. 8399-8698), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117624] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 386 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 34 of 88, (pp. 8699-8978), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117628] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 387 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 35 of 88, (pp. 8979-9278), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117634] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 388 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 36 of 88, (pp. 9279-9576), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117641] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 389 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 37 of 88, (pp. 9577-9876), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117646] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 390 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 38 of 88, (pp. 9877-10142), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117650] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 391 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 39 of 88, (pp. 10143-10402), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117655] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 392 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 40 of 88, (pp. 10403-10675), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117657] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 393 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 41 of 88, (pp. 10676-10962), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117663] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 394 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 42 of 88, (pp. 10963-11260), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117676] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 395 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 43 of 88, (pp. 11261-11535), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117682] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 396 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 44 of 88, (pp. 11536-11828), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117686] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 397 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 45 of 88, (pp. 11829-12096), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117725] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 398 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 46 of 88, (pp. 12097-12390), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117728] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 400 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 47 of 88, (pp. 12391-12633), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117736] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 401 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 48 of 88, (pp. 12634-12925), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117742] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 402 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 49 of 88, (pp. 12926-13220), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117752] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 403 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 50 of 88, (pp. 13221-13427), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117754] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 404 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 51 of 88, (pp. 13428-13719), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117766] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 405 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 52 of 88, (pp. 13720-13985), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117772] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 406 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 53 of 88, (pp. 13986-14256), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117779] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 407 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 54 of 88, (pp. 14257-14556), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117786] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 408 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 55 of 88, (pp. 14557-14856), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117789] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 409 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 56 of 88, (pp. 14857-15119), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117796] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 410 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 57 of 88, (pp. 15120-15409), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117821] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 411 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 58 of 88, (pp. 15410-15708), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117822] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
411 1 Appendix FILED (c)
411 2 Supporting Document
411 3 Supporting Document
2013-12-11 412 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 59 of 88, (pp. 15709-15990), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117904] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 413 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 60 of 88, (pp. 15991-16271), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117907] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 414 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 61 of 88, (pp. 16272-16570), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117912] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 415 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 62 of 88, (pp. 16571-16870), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117913] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 416 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 63 of 88, (pp. 16871-17170), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117922] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 417 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 64 of 88, (pp. 17171-17470), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117929] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 418 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 65 of 88, (pp. 17471-17768), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117935] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 419 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 66 of 88, (pp. 17769-18068), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117941] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 420 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 67 of 88, (pp. 18069-18302), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117945] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 421 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 68 of 88, (pp. 18303-18600), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117952] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 422 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 69 of 88, (pp. 18601-18887), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117955] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 423 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 70 of 88, (pp. 18888-19186), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117956] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 424 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 71 of 88, (pp. 19187-19480), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117963] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 425 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 72 of 88, (pp. 19481-19780), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117968] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 426 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 73 of 88, (pp. 19781-20080), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1117998] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 427 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 74 of 88, (pp. 20081-20380), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1118002] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 428 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 75 of 88, (pp. 20381-20680), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1118005] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 429 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 76 of 88, (pp. 20681-20960), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1118009] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 430 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 77 of 88, (pp. 20961-21254), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1118015] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 431 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 78 of 88, (pp. 21255-21550), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1118019] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 432 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 79 of 88, (pp. 21551-21826), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1118021] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 433 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 80 of 88, (pp. 21827-22082), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1118023] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 434 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 81 of 88, (pp. 22083-22319), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1118027] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 435 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 82 of 88, (pp. 22320-22560), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1118036] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 436 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 83 of 88, (pp. 22561-22838), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1118039] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 437 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 84 of 88, (pp. 22839-23091), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1118041] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 438 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 85 of 88, (pp. 23092-23380), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1118045] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 439 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 86 of 88, (pp. 23381-23680), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1118050] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 440 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 87 of 88, (pp. 23681-23980), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1118057] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 441 0 JOINT APPENDIX, volume 88 of 88, (pp. 23981-24149), on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1118062] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-11 444 0 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE for Joint Appendix, on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, City of New York in 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 12/11/2013 by hand delivery.[1118102] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2013-12-23 445 0 LETTER, advising the Court attorney Cardozo is withdrawing his appearance effective 12/31/2013, on behalf of Appellant City of New York, RECEIVED. Service date 12/23/2013 by CM/ECF.[1120952] [13-3088]--[Edited 12/23/2013 by JW] 2013-12-23 15:09:31 7be8c6a701bec9c47d10f87a35556e7ec5aa2ef3
2013-12-30 446 0 LETTER, requesting the Court to decide on the motion to intervene, on behalf of Movant Captains' Endowment Association of New York, Detectives Endowment Association, Police Department, City of New York, Inc., Lieutenants Benevolent Association of the City of New York, Inc. and Patrolmen's Benevolent Association of the City of New York, Inc., RECEIVED. Service date 12/30/2013 by CM/ECF.[1123820] [13-3088]--[Edited 01/02/2014 by JW] 2013-12-30 17:54:39 9cbb60eb7783f4db26db9e8a57f74103a8f9e0a6
2013-12-31 447 0 LETTER, advising the Court of the expiring term for this party, on behalf of Movant The Office of the Public Advocate for the City of New York, RECEIVED. Service date 12/31/2013 by CM/ECF.[1124115] [13-3088]--[Edited 01/17/2014 by JW] 2013-12-31 16:10:06 92f5a5b3d24a406bec86ae7c654d3a16118ef5d6
2013-12-31 448 0 LETTER, requesting the Court to decide on the motion to intervene, on behalf of Appellant Sergeants Benevolent Association, RECEIVED. Service date 12/31/2013 by CM/ECF.[1124330] [13-3088]--[Edited 01/02/2014 by JW] 2013-12-31 16:18:58 a947eaa10d436cedcf3a7794245cb470e43321eb
2014-01-21 455 0 ERRATA SHEET, for Non-Dispositive Per Curiam Opinion dated 11/22/2013, by JAC, FILED.[1137857] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]--[Edited 01/21/2014 by JW]
2014-01-21 456 0 ERRATA SHEET, for Non-Dispositive Per Curiam Opinion re: Motion, dated 11/13/2013, by JAC, FILED.[1137862] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2014-01-21 457 0 ERRATA SHEET, for Non-Dispositive Per Curiam Opinion dated 11/13/2013, by JAC, FILED.[1137867] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2014-01-24 458 0 CAPTION, in regards to plaintiffs-appellees and defendants, AMENDED.[1141175] [13-3088]
2014-01-30 459 0 MOTION, for Limited Remand to the District Court, on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 01/30/2014 by CM/ECF. [1145860] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]--[Edited 01/30/2014 by JW] 2014-01-31 03:21:33 4198f685e586c5e585ee3ad4c27e43f82d08d12d
2014-01-30 460 0 ORDER, dated 01/30/2014, ordering the proposed intervenors file a response by 02/07/2014 at noon to City of New York's motion seeking remand to the district court; parties may reply to the proposed intervenors' submission by 02/14/2014 at noon, by JAC, FILED.[1146030] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]--[Edited 01/30/2014 by DE] 2014-01-31 03:44:47 3f062c780a1789cd18447e7d8357d4604d9d7d4a
2014-02-03 462 0 ERRATA SHEET, for Non-Dispositive Per Curiam Opinion dated 11/22/2013, by JAC, FILED.[1148438] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2014-02-03 463 0 ERRATA SHEET, for Non-Dispositive Per Curiam Opinion re: Motion, dated 11/13/2013, by JAC, FILED.[1148439] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2014-02-03 464 0 ERRATA SHEET, for Non-Dispositive Per Curiam Opinion dated 11/13/2013, by JAC, FILED.[1148440] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2014-02-07 465 0 OPPOSITION TO MOTION for limited remand to the district court[459], on behalf of Movant Captains' Endowment Association of New York, Detectives Endowment Association, Police Department, City of New York, Inc., Lieutenants Benevolent Association of the City of New York, Inc. and Patrolmen's Benevolent Association of the City of New York, Inc., FILED. Service date 02/07/2014 by CM/ECF. [1152486][465] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]--[Edited 02/07/2014 by JW] 2014-02-07 11:35:32 72a46a4ed173f3f24fdcec5aa73a4b51b39c792c
2014-02-07 466 0 OPPOSITION TO MOTION for limited remand to the district court[459], on behalf of Appellant Sergeants Benevolent Association in 13-3088, FILED. Service date 02/07/2014 by CM/ECF. [1152565][466] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]--[Edited 02/07/2014 by JW]
2014-02-14 467 0 REPLY TO OPPOSITION [466], [465], on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 02/14/2014 by CM/ECF.[1156820][467] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2014-02-14 468 0 MOTION, for leave to respond, on behalf of Movant Rudolph W. Giuliani and Michael B. Mukasey, FILED. Service date 02/14/2014 by CM/ECF. [1156844] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2014-02-14 469 0 REPLY TO OPPOSITION [465], [466], on behalf of Appellee Lalit Clarkson, Deon Dennis, David Floyd and David Ourlicht, FILED. Service date 02/14/2014 by CM/ECF.[1156857][469] [13-3088]
2014-02-14 470 0 LETTER, on behalf of Movant Shira A. Scheindlin, RECEIVED. Service date 02/14/2014 by CM/ECF.[1156909] [13-3088]
2014-02-14 471 0 MOTION ORDER, granting motion for leave to respond [468] filed by Movant Michael B. Mukasey and Rudolph W. Giuliani in 13-3088, FILED. [1157249][471] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524] 2014-02-17 17:30:00 f57dfde4274e517de4bf8b28f468887411c958dd
2014-02-14 472 0 ORDER, dated 02/14/2014, setting plaintiffs' brief due date as 03/21/2014, defendants' reply brief due date as 04/04/2014, FILED.[1157263] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]--[Edited 02/14/2014 by JW]
2014-02-21 473 0 LETTER, removing the appearance for attorney Martini, on behalf of Appellee Lalit Clarkson, Deon Dennis, David Floyd and David Ourlicht, RECEIVED. Service date 02/21/2014 by CM/ECF.[1162487] [13-3088]--[Edited 02/21/2014 by JW]
2014-02-21 475 0 NEW CASE MANAGER, Yana Segal, ASSIGNED.[1162577] [13-3088]
2014-02-21 476 0 OPINION, granting the City's motion on terms indicated in this opinion, vacating the stay of proceedings in the District Court entered as part of the Court’s Orders of October 31, 2013 and November 13, 2013, In re Reassignment of 3 Cases, 736 F.3d 118 (2d Cir. 2013), to the extent necessary to pursue settlement negotiations among such concerned or interested parties as the District Court deems appropriate, and remanding the cause to the District Court (Analisa Torres, Judge) for further proceedings consistent with this opinion. The schedule for briefing and other filings in the Court of Appeals is hereby STAYED pending the outcome of the proceedings in the District Court. The mandate shall issue forthwith. Per curiam (JMW, JAC, BDP), FILED.[1162582] [13-3088]
2014-02-21 477 0 NEW CASE MANAGER, Yana Segal, ASSIGNED.[1162588] [13-3461]
2014-02-21 478 0 OPINION, granting the City's motion on terms indicated in this opinion, vacating the stay of proceedings in the District Court entered as part of the Court’s Orders of October 31, 2013 and November 13, 2013, In re Reassignment of 3 Cases, 736 F.3d 118 (2d Cir. 2013), to the extent necessary to pursue settlement negotiations among such concerned or interested parties as the District Court deems appropriate, and remanding the cause to the District Court (Analisa Torres, Judge) for further proceedings consistent with this opinion. The schedule for briefing and other filings in the Court of Appeals is hereby STAYED pending the outcome of the proceedings in the District Court. The mandate shall issue forthwith. Per curiam (JMW, JAC, BDP), FILED.[1162599] [13-3461]
2014-02-21 479 0 JUDGMENT MANDATE, ISSUED.[1162622] [13-3088, 13-3461]
2014-04-16 483 0 REQUEST FOR ARGUMENT CD From DREXEL with fee, RECEIVED.[1203270] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2014-08-06 484 0 MOTION, to withdraw appeal, on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 08/06/2014 by CM/ECF. [1288754] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524] 2014-08-08 20:30:21 bb0ef2e33a40b3322106863352e5f3839908813c
2014-08-08 487 0 OPPOSITION TO MOTION to withdraw appeal [484], on behalf of Appellant Sergeants Benevolent Association in 13-3088, 13-3461, FILED. Service date 08/08/2014 by CM/ECF. [1291023][487] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524] 2014-08-08 20:40:09 d9db38efe1d36b291872b3567d1c6357dd39ad91
2014-08-11 490 0 OPPOSITION TO MOTION to withdraw appeal [484], on behalf of Movant Captains' Endowment Association of New York, Detectives Endowment Association, Police Department, City of New York, Inc., Lieutenants Benevolent Association of the City of New York, Inc. and Patrolmen's Benevolent Association of the City of New York, Inc., FILED. Service date 08/11/2014 by CM/ECF. [1292208][490] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2014-08-14 494 0 ORDER, dated 08/14/2014, Briefing on the newly filed appeals and argument on all pending matters will be consolidated and expedited, with the following briefing schedule: Opening briefs for the appellants-putative intervenors shall be filed and served no later than 09/03/2014. Briefs of opposing parties shall be filed and served by no later than 09/24/2014. Reply briefs for the appellants-putative intervenors shall be filed and served by no later than 10/01/2014. Oral argument on these, and any other pending and relevant matters, shall be held on Wednesday, 10/15/2014, at 12:30 p.m. at the Fifteenth Floor Courtroom of the Court of Appeals, in the Thurgood Marshall U.S. Courthouse in Foley Square, New York, FILED.[1295764] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2014-08-18 495 0 REPLY TO OPPOSITION [490], [487], on behalf of Appellant City of New York in 13-3088, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 08/18/2014 by CM/ECF.[1297462][495] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2014-08-18 496 0 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS ADDITIONAL COUNSEL, on behalf of Appellee Lalit Clarkson, Deon Dennis, David Floyd and David Ourlicht in 13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 08/18/2014 by CM/ECF. [1297515] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2014-08-18 500 0 REPLY TO OPPOSITION [487], [490], on behalf of Appellee Lalit Clarkson, Deon Dennis, David Floyd and David Ourlicht in 13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 08/18/2014 by CM/ECF.[1298014][500] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2014-08-25 504 0 ARGUMENT NOTICE, to attorneys/parties, TRANSMITTED.[1304130] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2014-08-26 505 0 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS ADDITIONAL COUNSEL, on behalf of Appellee Lalit Clarkson, Deon Dennis, David Floyd and David Ourlicht in 13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524, FILED. Service date 08/26/2014 by CM/ECF. [1304707] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524]
2014-09-17 512 0 LETTER, on behalf of Movant Patrolmen's Benevolent Association of the City of New York, RECEIVED. Service date 09/17/2014 by CM/ECF.[1322426] [13-3088] [Entered: 09/17/2014 03:47 PM]
2014-09-25 514 0 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS ADDITIONAL COUNSEL, on behalf of Appellee Lalit Clarkson, Deon Dennis, David Floyd and David Ourlicht in 13-3088, FILED. Service date 09/25/2014 by CM/ECF. [1329177] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524] [Entered: 09/25/2014 01:14 PM]
2014-10-09 517 0 ORDER, dated 10/09/2014, in accordance with the orders issued on 10/31/2013, and 02/21/2014, the captioned matters will be heard by the panel that determined the stay and related applications, and in accordance with the order issued on 11/25/2013, all motions for en banc consideration remain in abeyance pending further order of the Court, FILED.[1340938] [13-3088] [Entered: 10/09/2014 12:17 PM]
2014-10-31 520 0 OPINION, Judge Torres’s July 30, 2014 decision is AFFIRMED as being an appropriate exercise of her discretion, the police unions’ motions to intervene in the appeals are DENIED, the City’s motion for voluntary dismissal of the appeals with prejudice is GRANTED, and the causes are REMANDED for such further proceedings before Judge Torres as may be appropriate in the circumstances. The mandate shall issue seven days from the date of the filing of this opinion, per curiam (JMW, JAC, BDP), FILED.[1359268] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524] [Entered: 10/31/2014 10:49 AM]
2014-10-31 521 0 CERTIFIED OPINION, dated 10/31/2014, to SDNY (NEW YORK CITY), ISSUED.[1359325] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524] [Entered: 10/31/2014 11:13 AM]
2014-11-07 526 0 ORDER, that the petitions are denied. The related FRAP 29 motions and requests to file supplemental documents are denied as moot, FILED.[1365562] [13-3088] [Entered: 11/07/2014 04:31 PM]
2014-11-07 527 0 JUDGMENT MANDATE, ISSUED.[1365576] [13-3088, 13-3461, 13-3524] [Entered: 11/07/2014 04:36 PM]